incacar
Open full version
Full version with search and research tools →
All articles

2019 Highlander LE V6 vs. Pilot LX: A Used-SUV Comparison

. Sources checked 2026-11-13. Verify current vehicle details and transaction terms before buying.
2019 Highlander LE photographed in Canada. Illustrative vehicle; US drivetrain specification is not established by the photograph. SsmIntrigue / Wikimedia Commons. Resized to WebP; image and derivatives: CC BY-SA 4.0.

A 2019 Highlander LE V6 and a 2019 Pilot LX both offer eight seats, but they deserve different checks at a viewing. Start with the Highlander if garage space is tight; put the Pilot first on your test-drive list if the third row will see frequent use. That is a shortlist based on dimensions, not a verdict on which used vehicle is in better condition.

This comparison covers US-market Highlander LE 3.5-liter V6 FWD and Pilot LX 3.5-liter V6 2WD. It does not cover the four-cylinder Highlander, Highlander Hybrid, AWD versions or higher Pilot trims. Match the VIN and original equipment information before using the numbers below.

The specifications that change the shopping list

2019 US specificationHighlander LE V6 FWDPilot LX 2WD
Engine output295 hp280 hp
Automatic transmission8-speed6-speed
Seats88
Length192.5 in196.5 in
Published width75.8 in78.6 in
Third-row legroom27.7 in31.9 in
EPA city / highway20 / 27 mpg19 / 27 mpg

Sources: Toyota's 2019 US brochure (manufacturer document hosted by Dealer eProcess) and Honda's 2019 US specifications. EPA estimates are comparison figures, not promised fuel consumption. Published width is not a clearance guarantee with mirrors and doors open. Sources checked November 13, 2026.

Test the third row with the second row occupied

The Pilot's published rear legroom makes it worth trying first for regular third-row passengers. But do not judge either SUV with the middle seats pushed forward into a position your family would never use. Set the driver's seat, settle a passenger in the second row, then try the back seat. Check foot space, head clearance and the route out.

Bring the actual child restraints if they are part of the plan. Follow both the restraint instructions and vehicle manual for an approved seating position; do not infer that eight seating positions mean eight suitable places for your particular arrangement. Our family SUV guide covers the broader passenger-fit decision.

2019 Pilot photographed in Canada. Illustrative vehicle, not a verified US LX 2WD example. Bull-Doser / Wikimedia Commons. Resized to WebP; image and derivatives: Public domain.

Measure the garage and load your own bags

The Highlander is four inches shorter in these published measurements. Before treating that as the deciding advantage, measure your parking space with room to walk around the car and operate the liftgate. At the viewing, check door opening clearance beside a neighboring vehicle rather than just whether the tires fit between painted lines.

For cargo, bring a stroller, suitcase or folded mobility aid that you actually carry. Load it with the third row in the position you need on a normal trip. A bag that fits only after folding a passenger's seat does not solve that trip. Try retrieving a small item without unloading everything else, too.

Do not let the transmission label replace an inspection

This Pilot LX uses a six-speed automatic; the nine-speed listed for higher trims is not the gearbox in this comparison. The selected V6 Highlander uses an eight-speed. Neither the number of gears nor a brand reputation establishes the condition of the car in front of you.

Arrange a drive from cold and again after warm-up. Note delayed engagement, harsh shifts, vibration or warning lights and give those observations to an independent mechanic. Do not diagnose the cause from a short drive or accept “they all do that” as a repair assessment. Our cold-start inspection checklist helps plan the appointment.

Turn service records into a first-year budget

Ask for dated invoices with mileage, not just a stamped book or an advertisement saying “fully serviced.” Have the shop compare those records with the manufacturer maintenance requirements for the exact engine, transmission and use conditions. Ask which items are due now, which are due within your expected first year, and which cannot be confirmed.

Price the identified work before negotiating. Two equally priced examples are not equal purchases if one needs tires, brakes and overdue service immediately. Keep separate amounts for documented work and unresolved inspection findings; a vague allowance can hide an expensive uncertainty.

Which one should make the final cut?

Choose between actual inspected examples after the passenger and parking tests. A useful decision sheet has four lines: fit for your passengers, fit for your space, documented condition, and purchase price plus immediate work. If one fails the daily-use test, a small fuel-economy difference will not fix it.

If neither gives you usable seating and luggage space at the same time, widen the search instead of forcing a choice. The sedan-versus-SUV guide can help reconsider which vehicle layout earns its space in your household.