Simple-Interest vs. Precomputed Auto Loans: Check the Payoff Terms

If you expect to make extra payments on a car loan, ask how interest is calculated before asking how much extra to send. “You can pay early” does not tell you how the lender determines the payoff or applies an additional payment.
Request the actual contract language. Have the lender point out the calculation method, payment-allocation rules and early-payoff provisions. Keep the written answer with the quote so you can compare another offer on the same basis.
Two methods, different questions
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau explains that simple interest uses the outstanding loan balance and is calculated daily or monthly. Precomputed interest is calculated at the start and incorporated into the repayment schedule.
With simple interest, reducing principal can reduce the balance on which later interest is calculated. With precomputed interest, do not assume an extra payment produces the same saving. CFPB notes that early payoff may involve a refund of some unearned interest. Ask how that refund is calculated and where it appears in the payoff quote.
The label alone is not a complete comparison. You still need the amount financed, APR, scheduled payments, total of payments and any relevant fees. Our used-car loan comparison guide helps organize the full offers; this article focuses on what happens when your repayment plan changes.
A small example of daily simple interest
Assume an outstanding principal balance of $12,000, a fixed annual interest rate of 9%, a 365-day calculation year and 30 days with no balance changes. Ignore fees and rounding until the end. These are illustrative assumptions, not a current market quote or your lender's calculation rules.
$12,000 × 0.09 × 30 ÷ 365 = $88.77 in interest for that period.
If principal were instead $11,000 throughout the same 30 days, the calculation would be $11,000 × 0.09 × 30 ÷ 365 = $81.37. The difference is about $7.40 for that period. It is not the lifetime saving from a $1,000 payment, and it assumes the lower balance was effective for the entire period.
Do not plug the APR into this example merely because it is the most prominent percentage on the disclosure. Confirm the contract interest rate and calculation basis. See our APR and interest-rate explanation for that separate distinction.
Ask what an extra payment actually does
Give the servicer a concrete scenario: “After my scheduled payment posts, I want to send another $1,000. How will you apply it, and what will the next statement show?” Ask whether instructions are needed, whether any accrued charges are paid first, and whether the next due date changes.
Then ask how you will verify the result. Save the confirmation and check the statement rather than relying on a payment-screen label. If the explanation differs from the contract, resolve that discrepancy before treating an estimated saving as money available for something else.
Separate a refund calculation from a penalty
CFPB's prepayment guidance says the contract and state law determine the early-payoff terms. Some states prohibit penalties for certain loans. Review the contract and Truth in Lending disclosures; do not infer the absence of a penalty from the words “simple interest.”
For a precomputed loan, ask about both the treatment of unearned interest and any separate charge for early repayment. A statement that one charge does not apply does not answer the other question. Get an itemized payoff for a specific date, with its expiration and payment instructions.
Compare the scenario you actually expect
- For scheduled repayment, compare the written payment schedule and total cost.
- For occasional extra payments, request a worked explanation of payment allocation.
- For an early sale or refinance, ask for an illustrative payoff at the same future point for each offer.
Keep assumptions consistent: the same amount financed, repayment dates and extra-payment plan. Do not select a loan on an unsupported promise that you can “always refinance later.” A clear written answer now is more useful than a calculator result built on the wrong method. Sources checked November 13, 2026; the cited CFPB pages show January 30, 2024 review dates.